Two pints on the bar, two lines sitting dead center on the G, and a table full of people all shouting a different winner. That's the moment you need a split the G tiebreaker, and it's a lot easier to settle if you picked one before anyone took a sip. This post covers the tiebreak formats that actually work, a simple scoring system that cuts down on ties in the first place, and a few referee rules that keep the night friendly. If you're new to the game, start with our Split the G page and come back when the arguments start.
Why you need a split the G tiebreaker before round one
Ties happen more often than you'd think. Once a group has played a few rounds, the good sippers start landing close to the middle of the letter, and "they both look perfect" turns into a regular problem. If the table decides how to break a tie after it happens, the person who's behind will always prefer a different method than the person who's ahead. Agree on it up front, say it out loud, and get a nod from everyone. It takes thirty seconds and saves you twenty minutes of debate.
It also helps to agree on what counts as a tie. Our suggestion is simple: if the judge can't honestly say which line is closer to the middle of the G after looking at both glasses side by side at eye level, it's a tie. Don't let anyone talk you into "mine was a hair better" from across the table.
A split the G scoring system that keeps ties rare
The fewer ways there are to tie, the less you'll need a tiebreaker at all. A plain "split or no split" game produces ties constantly, because two splits are just two splits. A graded scoring system spreads people out. Here's one that's easy to keep on a napkin:
- 3 points for a clean split, with the line running through the middle of the G.
- 2 points if the line lands on the G but clearly above or below the middle.
- 1 point if the line is within a finger's width of the letter.
- 0 points for anything further off, or for a second sip.
Play three or four rounds and add it up. Over several rounds, totals tend to separate on their own, and when they don't, you've got a clear tie to break instead of a fuzzy one. Keep a photo of every attempt taken straight on with the pint flat on the bar. Photos are what make most of the tiebreakers below possible.
Five tiebreak formats, from quickest to most dramatic
1. Countback
If two people finish on the same total, look at their best single round. Whoever has more 3-point rounds wins. Still level? Compare 2-point rounds. It's the same idea golf and plenty of other sports use, and it needs no extra Guinness, which makes it the fairest option when the group is ready to call it a night.
2. The photo comparison
Pull up the photos of each player's best attempt and put the phones side by side. The judge picks whose line sat closest to the center of the G. This works best when everyone used the same style of glass, so the G is in the same spot on every pint.
3. Sudden death sip-off
The classic. Both players get a fresh pint, the judge watches them go one after the other, and the closer line wins. If it's still a tie, go again. Two rules keep it fair: both pints should be poured at the same time so they've settled the same amount, and the player who went first in the last round goes second in the sudden death, so nobody gets the advantage of watching the other one twice.
4. Best of three
For a final where you want more than one sip to decide it, play three head-to-head rounds and the first to win two takes it. It's slower and it costs a couple more pints, but it rewards consistency rather than one lucky sip, and the room tends to get louder with every round.
5. The coin flip
Keep it in your pocket as the last resort. If you've done countback, compared photos and gone two sudden death rounds without separating them, flip a coin and buy the runner-up a pint. Nobody remembers who won a coin toss, but everybody remembers the sudden death that went four rounds.
Split the G referee rules for a tied finish
A tiebreaker is only as fair as the person calling it, so a few referee rules are worth adding for the decider:
- Use a neutral judge. Whoever is playing in the tiebreak can't call it. Hand the job to someone who's out of contention.
- Same pint for both. Matching glasses and pours poured together. A pint that's still settling isn't the same game as one that's been sitting there.
- Call it on the bar. Pint set down flat, judge's eyes level with the G, no calls on a glass still in someone's hand.
- The judge's call stands. Disagree all you like over the next round, but the result doesn't change.
For the tricky individual rulings (tilted lines, foam rings, spills), we've written a whole referee's notebook on judging the close calls.
Running a split the G challenge in Miami
Every format above depends on the pints being consistent. If one glass got a rushed pour and the other got a proper settle, you're not breaking a tie, you're measuring the bartender. At The Leinster every Guinness gets the two-part pour, 119.5 seconds with a settle in the middle, so the only variable left in a sudden death is the person drinking it. That's the same setup behind the Split the G Championship at our St. Patrick's party, which ran four rounds from 3PM and had the whole pub on its feet for the finals at 7PM.
A 20 oz Guinness is $10.50 on the menu, and during happy hour, Monday to Friday from 3 to 7 PM, Guinness is $5 before 5 PM, which makes a best of three a much easier sell. If somebody at the table is pacing themselves, Guinness 00, the alcohol-free one, is $8 and has the same G to aim at. And if you want a crowd for your decider, come in when a match is on. Our sports lineup runs with the sound up, and there's no better pressure test than a room full of fans watching your sip.
We're at 1600 NE 1st Ave in Edgewater, walk-ins only. Bring your crew, pick your tiebreaker before the first pint lands, and pull up a stool at The Leinster.
Hungry? Check out our full menu or swing by during Happy Hour for the best deals in Edgewater.
View Our Menu